AMERICAblog.com

Visit our stores
here and here

You are NOT on the AMERICAblog home page
click here to go there!

Check to have links open new windows
Send me your tips: americablog@starpower.net




Monday, May 05, 2008
But *which* militia?

by · 5/05/2008 11:48:00 AM ET · Link 
Discuss this post here: Make a comment · reddit · FARK · Digg It!


This NYT article on Iraq today is a good example of why it's so frustrating to try to follow news on Iraq through corporate media. Michael Gordon, who does some really good stuff on Iraq and often seems to fully understand the intricacies of the conflict, delivers up what reads like the stenography for which reporters are so often criticized by experts in various fields. In this case, the Bush administration is once again accusing Iran of causing problems in Iraq, this time by reportedly bringing in Hezbollah (an Arab, Lebanon-based Shia group formed to fight Israel and now a significant political and military force in Lebanon) officials to train Iraqi militia members. This is part of a continuing story in which the US blames problems in Iraq on nefarious neighbors, but anything is possible, so it's worth looking at the details of the report.

Or at least it would be if there *were any details* in the report. Most critically, it's important to note that there are many militias in Iraq. There's a (US-supported) Sunni militia in western Iraq (Anbar province), and in addition to several smaller tribal and political party-affiliated militias, the two major Shia political groups, ISCI and Sadrists, both have armed elements (the Badr Corps and the Mahdi Militia, respectively). So one would think an important detail of the story would be . . . which militia we're accusing Iran of training? Especially because the US has essentially come out in support of ISCI and its Badr Corps, as they are the main element keeping Prime Minister Maliki in power. Could the administration flacks be so cynical as to accuse Iran of training a "militia" that we tacitly support, and that is closely allied with our good buddy Maliki?

I suppose it's possible that the militia in question is the Mahdi Militia, but with Iran supposedly backing away from support of Sadrists, that seems less likely, and since the US opposes Mahdi so strongly, why not just say so if that's the case? The whole thing is very strange, and it's opaque to an extent that it's very suspicious.

Labels: , ,



You are NOT on the AMERICAblog home page, 
click here to read more posts about US Politics














days to 2008 election by whydemocrats.com

News sites:
- Washington Post
- NYT
- AP Politics
- Reuters Politics
- Editor & Publisher
- Rasmussen Polls
- Time
- Newsweek
- Roll Call
- The Hill

- ABCNews
- Bloomberg Politics
- Boston Globe
- CBS News
- Chicago Sun-Times
- Chicago Tribune
- Christian Science Monitor
- CNN
- Congressional Quarterly
- Dallas Morning News
- Dow Jones
- Houston Chronicle
- Los Angeles Times
- McClatchy
- Miami Herald
- NBC News
- NY Daily News
- New Republic
- NY Daily News blog
- NYT listing of blogs
- New Yorker
- NPR
- Philly Daily News
- Philly Inquirer
- SF Chronicle
- USA Today
- Vanity Fair
- Village Voice

Foreign
- Agence France-Presse
- Al Jazeera
- Asia Times
- BBC
- Der Spiegel (Germany, in English)
- Economist
- Financial Times
- Guardian (UK)
- Haaretz (Israel)
- Independent (UK)
- International Herald Tribune
- Jerusalem Post
- Le Monde (in French)
- Le Monde Diplomatique (in English)
- Times of India
- Times of London
- Yahoo, World News (in French)
- Yahoo, Latin American News (in Spanish)

Opinion
- Jonathan Alter
- Eric Boehlert
- Eleanor Clift
- Joe Conason
- E.J. Dionne, Jr.
- Maureen Dowd
- Dan Froomkin
- Mark Morford
- Frank Rich
- Helen Thomas

Political Cartoons
- Daryl Cagle
- Jeff Danziger
- Doonesbury
- Mark Fiore
- Mike Luckovich
- Pat Oliphant
- Ted Rall
- Tom Toles

Gossip
- Defamer
- Gawker
- Liz Smith
- Page Six
- Perez Hilton
- Reliable Source (Wash Post)
- Wonkette
- Yahoo Celebrity News


Donate to
AMERICAblog Candidates
Scott Kleeb (NE-Senate)
Donna Edwards (MD-04)
Tom Allen (ME-Senate)

Our blog RSS:

What is RSS?




AMERICAblog on Facebook

Buy an ad on all the top liberal blogs at once, over 2 million page views daily, here.

The anti-spam service I use and recommend:


My side-by-side comparison of religious right anti-gay speech and Nazi anti-Jewish propaganda. Is it similar? You decide.


Our podcast via iTunes:





Give to AMERICAblog

One-time donation
$
Recurring monthly donation
$
Donations are not tax-deductible.

Why AMERICAblog?
Because at some point you tire of the lies.

What issues do you cover?
US politics overall with a particular focus on the Bush Administration, the radical right, and civil rights.

Who are you?
- John Aravosis, Washington, DC
- Joe Sudbay, Washington, DC
- Chris Ryan, Paris, France
- A.J. (Alex) Rossmiller, Ann Arbor, Michigan
- Jacki Schechner, Washington, DC
- Cliff Schecter, Somewhere in Ohio

This page is powered by Blogger.
Copyright 2008 - John Aravosis